What Reviewers Look For in the Common App Supplemental Essay — Diversity / Perspective
This rubric looks for a clear source of perspective, how it changed the way you notice, question, interpret, or decide, and—when the prompt asks for it—how that perspective guides your actions or contributions. It helps ensure that your response answers the school’s actual prompt rather than relying on labels, broad values, or a generic campus promise.
What We Check
Whether the response identifies a lived context, background, experience, responsibility, sustained interest, or viewpoint and makes the resulting perspective recoverable.
The visible consequence in judgment or interpretation: what the student now notices, questions, distinguishes, understands, or decides differently from their own earlier or default view or action.
Whether the perspective affects an interaction, later choice, behavior, decision, or way of engaging beyond the source moment.
Completion of the exact supplied prompt's shaping, difference, viewpoint, source, peer-learning, enrichment, or contribution arms.
Mistakes We Flag
- Listing identities without explaining your perspective
- Demographics, labels, or background details alone do not show what perspective you gained. Explain what you notice, question, understand, or interpret because of a specific experience or context.
- Using “empathetic” or “open-minded” as the whole explanation
- A broad value does not show how your thinking changed. Name one way your view, assumption, attention, or decision-making shifted from your earlier or default approach.
- Claiming to be more unique or diverse than others
- The essay should focus on your own perspective, not compare you with other applicants. Hardship, rarity, or identity does not automatically demonstrate insight.
- Making a vague contribution promise
- Saying you will “bring diversity” or “enrich campus” does not show what you will actually do. If the prompt asks about contribution, describe a specific interaction, decision, or way of engaging.
- Answering a different school’s prompt
- A generic campus pitch can replace the perspective evidence the prompt requests, and references to another institution can remain by mistake. Address each visible part of the supplied prompt directly.
References
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need to write about a protected identity?
No. A place, language, family role, access context, sustained interest, ordinary background, responsibility, or formative experience can also provide the basis for a perspective.
Do I need a dramatic hardship story or an unusual background?
No. Hardship severity, rarity, and unusual background are not required. What matters is showing a perspective and its consequence.
Should I always include how I will contribute on campus?
Only if the supplied prompt asks about contribution, engagement, peer learning, impact, or perspective in use. If it asks only how you were shaped, you do not need to add a campus contribution.
How long should this response be?
Follow the exact limit supplied with the school’s prompt. If no limit is visible, do not assume a standard length.
Get your essay scored across all 4 dimension with specific, actionable feedback. Two free reviews per day — no credit card required.
See how common app essay review works