Employer or Attorney Letter for Law School: Sample
For managers, attorneys and judges asked for a law school letter: what six schools say about non-professor letters, a labeled sample, and when to decline.
Employer or Attorney Letter for Law School: Sample
A law school letter from an employer or attorney works when it reports the applicant's own reasoning and writing that you supervised. Yale Law School's tip sheet, last updated August 2026, says professional recommenders are most useful when they can speak to "the skills most relevant to the study of the law, including your relevant academic abilities".
Our view: a professional letter for law school still has to answer an academic question. A supervising attorney who edited the applicant's memos for two years has more to say than a judge who hosted a six-week internship, and the letter should be written by whoever read the work. Below: what six schools publish about letters from non-professors, a test for whether you are the right writer, and a constructed sample letter from a supervising attorney. You can test your own draft with a free review of the letter.
Every school, LSAC and court page quoted here was checked on November 19, 2026. If you taught the applicant, use the law school recommendation letter professor sample instead.
What law schools say about letters from employers
| School | On professional letters, verbatim |
|---|---|
| Yale tip sheet (last updated 08.2026) | "Professional recommenders are generally most useful when they can speak with authority on (i) the skills most relevant to the study of the law, including your relevant academic abilities, or (ii) your interest and expertise in a subject matter area related to your legal interests." |
| Yale application page | Substitute letters "should address the qualities that academic recommendations typically address, for example: the applicant's ability to write and think critically, as well as their overall suitability for the study and practice of law." |
| Duke | "A second letter should come from someone who can address your professional and work-related accomplishments, interpersonal skills, leadership, and involvement, such as a supervisor or advisor from a job, internship, or student organization." |
| Columbia (Fall 2027 application) For degrees from 2024 and earlier: "Applicants with substantive work experience who are not recent graduates are strongly encouraged to submit one professional letter and at least one academic letter of recommendation." | |
| Cornell | "Recommendation letters from internship or work supervisors are also taken into strong consideration." |
| Harvard | Applicants out of school for several years "may submit letters from employers or others who have worked closely with them." |
| Stanford | "If you have been out of school for a significant period you may substitute one letter from an employer or business associate." |
The schools do not agree on internships. Duke and Cornell name internship supervisors as acceptable writers. Yale's tip sheet lists, under "Whom should you avoid?", "Letters from internship supervisors (given the relatively limited duration of those roles)." Your letter may go to all three, so a short supervision period has to be stated plainly and backed by work you read yourself.
Yale's avoid list also names "Family members, friends, and peers" and "'Big name' recommenders with little direct insight into your abilities". Duke says "Letters from friends, family friends, and relatives are discouraged."
Are you the right writer? Decide by evidence, not title
One test, ours: did you assign, read or correct the applicant's reasoning or writing?
| Writer | What you can report first-hand | Write it? |
|---|---|---|
| Supervising attorney who assigned and edited a paralegal's memos | Their analysis on paper, over months or years | Yes |
| Manager who read their reports, proposals or analyses for a year or more | Reasoning, writing, how they took correction | Yes |
| Commanding officer, charge nurse, principal, coach | Conduct and reliability; reasoning only if you reviewed their written or analytical work | Only if the test is met |
| Judge or attorney who hosted a short internship | One or two pieces of work, if you read them yourself | Only if you read the work; say how long it was |
| Coworker at the same level | Yale lists "peers" under whom to avoid | No; point them to a supervisor |
| Partner, judge or official who knows the family | Nothing first-hand | No |
Yale's line for this is "Always choose substance over signature! It is far more important for your recommender to know you well than for us to recognize their name."
The countercase: some applicants have no professor to ask and one workplace. Stanford's page allows that applicant "two nonacademic letters", and Yale's says professional recommenders "can be an excellent substitute". Then both letters carry the academic question, and each should cover different work.
Writing about legal work without inflating it
For attorneys, three rules of ours:
- Separate their work from yours. Say what the paralegal or clerk did (document review, chronologies, first drafts) and what stayed with the lawyers. A letter that credits a paralegal with legal strategy reads as inflated. The applicant's own essay faces the same line; see the law school personal statement about paralegal work.
- Describe the kind of matter, not the client. Your confidentiality obligations decide what you may say. A letter needs the task, the volume and what the applicant did with it.
- Report one piece of writing you corrected. What the first draft got wrong, what you said, what came back.
Constructed sample letter from a supervising attorney, annotated
Constructed example, written by us, not a real letter, applicant or attorney. Context (invented): a partner at a small employment firm writes a general letter for a paralegal she supervised for two years. The letter is 351 words, salutation and signature included.
Dear Admissions Committee,
I recommend Tomas Rivera for admission to law school. I am a partner at a twelve-lawyer firm that represents employees in wage and discrimination cases. Mr. Rivera worked for me as a litigation paralegal from June 2024 to August 2026. I assigned his work, read nearly everything he wrote, and met with him weekly.
His job was document review, chronologies and first drafts of research memos. Legal conclusions, advice to clients and everything filed with a court stayed with the attorneys. Within those limits he did work I did not expect from a paralegal. In one overtime matter I asked him for a chronology of a client's schedule changes. He delivered it with a two-page memo I had not requested. He had noticed that the employer's timekeeping records and its own scheduling emails disagreed on eleven dates. He set the two side by side and listed three explanations, with the documents that supported and undercut each. He did not tell me which explanation was right. He told me which documents would settle it. His table became the outline for my deposition questions.
His writing is short and checkable. Every factual sentence in his memos carries a document number, and when I spot-checked them the documents said what he said they did. His first memos buried the answer on the last page. I told him so once; after that, each memo opened with it. He is slower than our senior paralegals on large document sets, because he reads rather than skims. On deadline that cost us time twice, and he learned to flag early when a review would run long.
I have supervised eleven paralegals since 2017. For written analysis and care with facts, Mr. Rivera is one of the two best. For speed he is in the middle of that group.
I recommend him for the study of law without reservation. He writes clearly, he checks what he is told, and he changes his mind when a document gives him a reason to. I can be reached at the address on the LSAC form.
Sincerely,
M. Achterberg Partner
What each paragraph does, against the published wording:
| Paragraph | What it proves | Published line it answers |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Role, dates, how closely she supervised | Basis for judgment | LSAC form: "how well you know the candidate and in what capacity" |
| 2. His tasks, the lawyers' tasks, the unrequested memo | Analysis on paper, without inflating the role | Yale: "the skills most relevant to the study of the law" |
| 3. Checkable writing; two bounded weaknesses | Writing, with candor | LSAC form: "candid appraisal"; Yale application page: "ability to write and think critically" |
| 4. Eleven paralegals since 2017; top two for analysis, middle for speed | A comparison with a named group | LSAC form: "relative strength of the candidate within the reference group" |
| 5. Plain endorsement, no school named | A letter every assigned school can read | LSAC: "You need to request only one 'general' letter when the content is the same." |
The letter names no client, gives no case outcome and claims no legal judgment for the paralegal. It also skips the résumé. The LSAC form says "Do not send supporting materials (e.g., résumés) with your letter."
Comparisons a manager can make
The LSAC form asks for "relative strength … within the reference group". At work, the group is the people you have supervised in the same role. Give its size and years, and the thing you are ranking.
Constructed example: a workplace comparison, weak and revised
Constructed examples, written by us, not lines from real letters.
- Weak: "She consistently exceeds expectations and is a top performer."
- Revised: "Of the 14 analysts I have managed since 2020, she is one of the three whose written recommendations I could send to a client without editing."
The weak line is a performance-review rating. A law school reader cannot tell what the expectations were or who else was rated. The revised line names the group, the window and the skill.
Judges: one more question before you write
Whether and how a judge may write a recommendation is decided under the judge's own code of conduct. For federal judges, Canon 2B of the Code of Conduct for United States Judges (last revised March 12, 2019) says "A judge should neither lend the prestige of the judicial office to advance the private interests of the judge or others". State judges answer to their own state's code and its advisory body.
If you may write, the admissions test is the same as for any writer: what did you read?
Constructed example: a judge's paragraph, weak and revised
Constructed examples, written by us, not paragraphs from real letters. Context (invented): a judge writes for a six-week summer intern.
- Weak: "In nineteen years on this court I have seen many young people pass through my chambers, and Ms. Lindqvist stands out as a person of excellent character who will make a fine attorney."
- Revised: "Ms. Lindqvist was a summer intern in my chambers for six weeks in 2026. I assigned her one bench memo, on whether a late-filed motion could be heard, and I read both drafts. The second corrected a misreading of the deadline rule that I had pointed out in the first. Six weeks and one memo are the whole of what I saw."
The weak paragraph rests on the office. The revised one states the short duration that Yale's tip sheet flags and reports the one piece of work the judge read.
When to decline
Decline if the table above says no: you know the family, you are a peer, or you never read the applicant's work. Decline if your employer's policy limits you to confirming dates of employment. Tell the applicant yourself and early. LSAC's recommender FAQ says "contact the applicant immediately" because "LSAC does not contact the applicant if you choose not to respond". Wording for that message is in how to decline writing a recommendation letter.
Checklist before you upload
- The first paragraph gives your role, the applicant's role, and the dates you supervised them.
- The letter says what the applicant did and what stayed with you or the lawyers.
- One paragraph reports one piece of their reasoning or writing that you read.
- The comparison names a group, its size and its years.
- Any weakness is stated with its limit.
- No client names, no confidential facts, no case outcomes credited to the applicant.
- A general letter says "Dear Admissions Committee" and names no school.
- No résumé or work sample is attached.
You send one letter to LSAC, not to each school. The steps are in the LSAC letter upload guide for recommenders, and length norms are in how long a letter of recommendation should be.
For part-time JD applicants, the employer's letter can confirm the schedule; the reason itself is yours to state.
Get a free review of the letter
Get a free Quick Review of your recommendation letter before you upload it. It uses GradPilot's general graduate school recommendation letter rubric (there is no law-specific letter rubric) and reads how you know the candidate, incidents instead of adjectives, comparisons that name their group, and the strength of your endorsement. GradPilot's letter reviews aren't for a letter an applicant drafted for a recommender to submit as their own.
Applicant reading this? The employer letter of recommendation guide for graduate school covers how to ask a manager, and law school recommendation letters when you are years out of school covers which writers to pick. More guides are in the law school essays hub, and the recommendation letter review page explains how letter reviews work.
Sources
Retrieved November 19, 2026.
- Yale Law School, Letters of Recommendation Tip Sheet (last updated 08.2026): professional recommenders, whom to avoid, substance over signature.
- Yale Law School, Application components (updated as of July 2026): what substitute letters should address.
- Duke Law, JD application (2026–27): second letter from a supervisor or advisor; friends and relatives discouraged.
- Columbia Law School, Fall 2027 J.D. preview application, PDF: professional letter for earlier graduates.
- Cornell Law School, JD FAQ (no year stated): internship and work supervisors.
- Harvard Law School, JD application components (Fall Term 2027 enrollment): letters from employers.
- Stanford Law School, JD application process (Fall 2027): employer substitutes, two nonacademic letters.
- LSAC, Letter of Recommendation Form, sample PDF (undated sample): recommender block, no supporting materials.
- LSAC, JD Services FAQs (undated): one general letter.
- LSAC, Applicant References FAQs (undated): declining a request.
- United States Courts, Code of Conduct for United States Judges (last revised March 12, 2019): Canon 2B.
Writing a law school recommendation letter?
Paste your letter. The free Quick Review shows what to strengthen against the public graduate recommendation letter rubric.